Property Management

Experience The Prime Difference!

Nestled in the peaceful mountains of Western Maryland, Prime Vacation Rentals is a trusted leader in property management with more than two decades of experience and a specialized focus on vacation rentals in the Deep Creek Lake area. We are a family-owned and operated business based right here in the Deep Creek community. We live here, employ locally, and proudly support the area we call home—bringing true local knowledge and care to every property we manage.

At Prime Vacation Rentals, we’re more than just managers—we’re caretakers. Every home is treated as if it were our own, guided by strong family values, honesty, and meticulous attention to detail. Our mission is simple: to provide an exceptional vacation experience for guests while protecting your property and maximizing your investment. Transparency, reliability, and open communication are at the foundation of everything we do, giving owners confidence and peace of mind.

Prime Vacation Rentals is led by founder and owner Jay Hott, whose hands-on approach and more than 20 years of management experience have established him as a trusted leader in property management at Deep Creek Lake. Jay’s keen eye for detail, extensive knowledge of maintenance and repairs, and straightforward communication style ensure every property is managed with care and professionalism. His commitment to owners has helped maintain a 100% owner satisfaction rate, even in challenging situations.

Supporting Jay’s leadership is his wife, Tabby Hott, who plays a key role in the day-to-day operations and guest relations at Prime Vacation Rentals. Tabby oversees administrative operations and helps shape our customer service approach, ensuring responsive, efficient support and a seamless experience from start to finish for guests and homeowners alike.

As a local family-operated business, we provide hands-on oversight, clear communication, and genuine accountability. This is what we call The Prime Difference! We live and work in the Deep Creek area, manage homes as if they were our own, and believe owners deserve clear communication and honest answers at every step. It’s a level of service that simply can’t be replicated by large, corporate management companies. When challenges arise, owners don’t deal with call centers or rotating staff—they work directly with a dedicated local team that knows their property inside and out. The result is consistent care, satisfied owners, and exceptional guest experiences.

We hope you choose Prime Vacation Rentals for proven results, local expertise, and true peace of mind. Contact us today to discover how we can elevate your property management experience.

Homeowner Testimonial

I am writing to offer my strong recommendation for Jay Hott of Prime Vacation Rental Properties in Deep Creek Lake. Having worked with Jay, I can confidently say that he stands out as a property manager who is both fair and highly effective. Jay is refreshingly straightforward and does not nickel and dime property owners. His approach is transparent and grounded in a clear understanding of what actually benefits both owners and guests. He knows the Deep Creek Lake market extremely well and uses that knowledge to make smart, timely decisions. From the start, Jay increased our revenue immediately through thoughtful pricing strategies and close attention to property performance. Unlike many property managers at the lake, who appear stretched too thin, Jay is hands-on and detail-oriented. He will only take on a limited number of properties so he can pay close attention to each property and respond quickly and thoughtfully to issues as they arise. Jay brings professionalism, market insight, and integrity to his work, and I would recommend him without hesitation to any property owner looking for reliable and effective management.

Stephanie Balian

Homeowner Testimonial

I am pleased to write this recommendation letter on behalf of Prime Vacation Rentals. Having experienced their services firsthand, I can confidently say that they set the standard for excellence in the Deep Creek vacation rental industry. From the moment we hired them to manage our vacation rental, the team at Prime Vacation Rentals demonstrated professionalism, responsiveness, and they genuinely care about your property.

The level of personal service and availability to answer questions or address a problem is much better than the 2 large vacation rental management companies in the area. Their fee structure is very competitive and the transparency of how the financials work is much better than other companies that we used/interviewed during the first year that we owned the property. Prime Vacation Rentals also does not nickel and dime you with unnecessary charges and their cleaning fee is very fair. What truly sets Prime Vacation Rentals apart is their commitment to customer satisfaction. They go above and beyond to accommodate the owner and the guest, and their proactive approach made us feel valued and cared for throughout our time with the company. Whether it was a special request or a last-minute change, their flexibility and dedication was remarkable. I found Jay Hott to be a fantastic proprietor and always willing to go the extra mile to help us out, which was very comforting when you are 3-4 hours away from the house.

Based on my positive experience, I wholeheartedly recommend Prime Vacation Rentals to anyone seeking a reliable, welcoming, and top-notch vacation rental Property Manager. They deliver on their promises and consistently provide excellent service.

James Neubauer

More Bang For Your Buck

Marketing

Despite being a small company, our strong partnerships give us access to major advertising platforms like VRBO, Airbnb Booking.com and more, to ensure your property gets the same visibility as larger companies.

Guest services

We handle all guest inquiries, bookings, and personalized experiences, ensuring seamless stays with quick responses and exceptional service from start to finish.

Property Care

We provide comprehensive care, including professional housekeeping, routine maintenance, and meticulous hot tub servicing to keep your property in great condition and fully operational for every guest.